loader

When and How Will Your Car Insurance Cover Theft?

Nov 05, 2025

Auto Insurance

When and How Will Your Car Insurance Cover Theft?

Every year, hundreds of thousands of cars are stolen across the U.S. costly, stressful ordeal for vehicle owners. The good news: car insurance can help protect you if theft happens, but you'll need the right coverage and to follow the right steps.

What Coverage Protects Against Theft?

Car insurance theft coverage is only available through comprehensive auto insurance policies. If your car is stolen or damaged during a theft attempt, comprehensive coverage pays for the loss up to your vehicle's actual cash value, minus your deductible. Liability or collision coverage alone will not protect you against theft, even in California.

What Does Comprehensive Coverage Pay for?

  • Theft of your entire car: Your insurer pays its actual cash value (ACV) if not recovered, less your deductible.
  • Break-in damage (windows, locks): Repairs are covered by comprehensive insurance.
  • Stolen auto parts: Items like airbags, catalytic converters, or stereo systems may be covered if pre-installed.
  • Personal property stolen from the car: Not covered by auto insurance; instead, file this with your homeowners or renters insurance.

What to Do if Your Car Is Stolen

  1. File a police report immediately: Provide details and get a report or case number.
  2. Contact your insurance company within 24 hours: Give them the police report and vehicle info
  3. Insurance company investigation: They'll verify theft, review your coverage and deductible, and may inspect the theft site.
  4. Claim payout: If unrecovered, you'll receive ACV; if found, damages will be assessed and covered.

How Long Does It Take?

Payouts for theft claims typically take 30-45 days, but factors like police investigation, vehicle recovery, and policy details can extend the timeline.

What If My Vehicle Is Recovered?

If your car is recovered after the claim, insurers may keep the vehicle and auction it, sharing proceeds minus the deductible and salvage value.

Preventing Vehicle Theft

Taking preventive steps can reduce your risk and sometimes lower your premium:

  • Always lock your car and take your keys
  • Park in well-lit places
  • Use alarms, steering wheel locks or immobilizers
  • Add anti-theft or vehicle recovery devices
  • Never leave valuables visible

U.S. Auto Theft Trends

Over 850,000 vehicles were stolen in the U.S. in 2024, a car stolen every 37 seconds. Summer months see the most thefts, with California consistently ranking high on theft rates.

Is Your Car Insurance Ready to Protect Your Ride?

Don't wait until it's too late! Reach out to John E. Peakes Insurance Agency today for a FREE policy review. Our team will help you assess your coverage and provide customized solutions to shield your vehicle against theft and break-ins. Call now at 1-800-800-5199, or contact us today to get in touch with our Ventura or Lancaster offices for expert, hassle-free assistance!

Links & Resources

FAQs on Car Insurance Theft Coverage

  1. Does liability-only insurance cover vehicle theft?

    No, you must have comprehensive coverage for car insurance theft coverage.

  2. What documents do I need to file a theft claim?

    You’ll need a copy of your police report, policy details, and vehicle information (VIN, plate, make/model).

  3. Are custom or aftermarket parts covered?

    Custom parts installed by the manufacturer may be covered; check your policy for specifics

  4. How are payouts calculated?

    Insurers pay the actual cash value (ACV) of your car minus your deductible.

Contact Us

CAPTCHA